Custom cakes, fresh pastries, and handmade desserts—crafted from three generations of perfected recipes. From wedding cakes to fresh morning donuts, we make every occasion unforgettable.
Everything is baked in-house using time-honored family recipes. If it's on this list, it was made fresh today.
13 specialty and 7 traditional flavors—including our beloved White Rhapsody. Available as round, sheet, square, or heart-shaped. Custom decorations for any occasion.
View Pricing →From kids' birthdays to Sweet 16s, our custom birthday cakes come in all flavors and sizes. Join our Birthday Club for $3 off every year.
Order Yours →Rich, buttery danish with fruit and cream cheese. Gooey sticky buns with cinnamon and butter. Whoopie pies in chocolate, red velvet, and pumpkin. Ready at 7 AM.
Come Visit →Handmade cream puffs, cannoli, chocolate cups, fresh fruit tarts, petit fours, dipped strawberries, and more—perfect for weddings, showers, and parties.
Request Pricing →Shoo-fly, pecan, egg custard, coconut cream, pumpkin, lemon sponge—plus fresh-baked cookies from soft sugar to chocolate chip. Local favorites, made properly.
Find Us →Fresh orange, lemon poppy-seed, blueberry, pumpkin, and cranberry-orange quick breads. Plus a fresh assortment of donuts, available every morning by 7 AM.
Call to Check →We know your wedding cake isn't just dessert—it's a centerpiece, a memory, and a reflection of your love. Our specialist, Diahann, will work with you from concept to creation.
Sit down with Diahann to discuss your vision, flavors, and design. No commitment required.
Every wedding cake is one-of-a-kind, designed specifically for your big day.
From classic white to the signature White Rhapsody with raspberry mousse and chocolate shavings.
Our wedding cake was absolutely stunning and tasted even better than it looked. Diahann was wonderful to work with—patient, creative, and clearly passionate. We got so many compliments from guests.
The White Rhapsody cake is worth every penny. My family requests it for every birthday. Three generations of recipes shows in every single bite. Best bakery in Lancaster, full stop.
I drove 45 minutes specifically for their sticky buns and whoopie pies. Worth every mile. The staff at the Roots Market are always friendly and have great suggestions. Don't miss this place.
Three generations of love, craft, and perfected recipes—baked fresh every single day in Leola, Pennsylvania.
Byers Butterflake Bakery has been a cornerstone of Lancaster County for generations. What started as a deep passion for quality baking has grown into a beloved local institution—trusted by families for some of life's most meaningful moments.
Nothing is mass-produced. Every item is made in-house using our original family recipes.
Find us at Roots Market in Manheim and New Eastern Market in York, not just in Leola.
From birthday cakes to wedding centerpieces, every order is personal and personalized.
Our recipes have been perfected across three generations—tested and treasured.
All cakes are available in traditional or specialty flavors. Prices include standard buttercream decorations. Custom artwork and licensed characters are priced separately—call us to discuss.
| Cake Type & Size | Serves | Traditional Flavor | Specialty Flavor |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sheet Cakes | |||
| ¼ Sheet | ~15 | $36 | $43 |
| ½ Sheet | 30–35 | $62 | $72 |
| Full Sheet | 60–70 | $100 | $130 |
| Round Cakes | |||
| 8″ Round | ~15 | $36 | $43 |
| 9″ Round | 20–25 | $48 | $58 |
| 10″ Round | 25–35 | $62 | $72 |
| 12″ Round | 35–45 | $96 | $115 |
| Square & Heart Cakes | |||
| 8″ Square | 20–25 | $48 | $58 |
| 9″ Square | ~30 | $63 | $75 |
| 8″ Heart | 10–12 | $36 | $45 |
| 9″ Heart | 18–20 | $48 | $58 |
| 10″ Heart | ~25 | $62 | $75 |
All cakes include standard buttercream flowers, balloons, and confetti decorations.
Need something custom? Call us at (717) 656-6803 — we love working with you.
Sign up with your name, birthday, and email address. We'll send you a coupon for $3 off your birthday cake—redeemable any time during your birth month.
Visit us in Leola, or find us at Roots Market in Manheim and New Eastern Market in York.
44 West Main Street
Leola, Pennsylvania
Mon–Fri: 7 AM – 5 PM
Saturday: 7 AM – 2 PM
✅ Online orders available for pickup here. Curbside by request.
Get Directions →705 Graystone Road
Manheim, Pennsylvania
Tuesdays only
Market hours apply
Come find our stand inside Roots Country Market for fresh baked goods.
Get Directions →201 Memory Lane
York, Pennsylvania
Fridays only
Market hours apply
Our York presence—friendly staff, full selection of pastries and baked goods.
Get Directions →For birthday and special occasion cakes, we recommend ordering at least one week in advance. For wedding cakes, we suggest booking your consultation 3–6 months before your wedding date to ensure availability.
Yes! When you schedule a free consultation with Diahann, we'll arrange for you to taste various cake flavors and discuss design options. Call (717) 656-6803 to set up your appointment.
Online orders can be placed through our website and picked up at our Leola location. Pickup times are available Monday–Friday 7 AM–5 PM and Saturday 7 AM–2 PM. Curbside delivery is available by request.
Please call us at (717) 656-6803 to discuss your specific needs. We want to make sure every celebration is special, and we'll do our best to accommodate your request.
We offer 7 traditional flavors and 13 specialty flavors, including our signature White Rhapsody—a white cake with chocolate shavings, raspberry marmalade, raspberry mousse, and buttercream icing. Call for the full current list.
Absolutely. Our miniature dessert trays are perfect for weddings, bridal showers, graduation parties, and corporate events. Email info@byersbakery.com for custom pricing on dessert orders.
We make ordering easy. Call us directly, place an order online, or come visit one of our locations. Our friendly staff is ready to help.
We receive your message and respond within one business day.
We confirm your order details, date, and pickup time.
Your order is baked fresh and ready for you at pickup.
Three generations of baking. Hundreds of cakes. Thousands of happy customers. Let us be part of your most important moments—from everyday mornings to once-in-a-lifetime wedding days.